Last week it was announced that Chinese people have stolen software from world’s biggest chip manufacturer ASML. Not much later, a Dutch news paper called Financieele Dagblad and multiple Dutch politicians spoke about state espionage. The Chinese government would be behind the espionage. However, ASML CEO Peter Wennink soon denied this story. Today Wennink revealed in an interview on Dutch television who is truly responsible. It’s not the Chinese government, but ‘our biggest Korean customer’.

Samsung ASML

Samsung was behind the theft of the ASML software

The interviewer from NOS Journal directly asked whether he meant Samsung, after which Wennink repeated ‘our biggest Korean customer’. Although the CEO did not want to call Samsung by name, it seems clear this Korean company is behind the espionage. ASML came to this conclusion after hiring an external company to find out who was behind the theft.

They concluded it is not state espionage, but ordinary business espionage. Chinese former employees have stolen the software to set up their own company, Xtal, to become an ASML competitor and a cheap alternative for Samsung. The spies are all born in China, but some now have the American nationality. The company Xtal is also setup in the United States.

The software was needed to set up chip machines for optimum production of electronic chips. In 2016, Samsung became a 30% shareholder of Xtal, and ASML subsequently lost Samsung as a customer for this software.

Samsung is a major client of ASML, it’s unclear whether and how their relationship will continue after this striking affair. Regarding the stolen software, Samsung is already back as an ASML customer.

About ASML

ASML provides chipmakers with everything they need – hardware, software and services – to mass produce patterns on silicon, helping to increase the value and lower the cost of a chip. Their key technology is the lithography system, which brings together high-tech hardware and advanced software to control the chip manufacturing process down to the nanometer. All of the world’s top chipmakers like Samsung, Intel and TSMC use technology from ASML. ASML has 19,000 employees worldwide and is headquartered in Veldhoven, The Netherlands, with over 60 offices in 16 countries.

China is an increasing important client for ASML. In 2018 about 19% of the turnover of ASML machines came from China. A year earlier this was only 11%. Therefore the news that was initially spread by the Dutch financial newspaper Financieele Dagblad was simply too harmful for ASML to stay silent. Wennink feels the story was ‘blown up’ and ‘out of context’.

With the development of the 5G network, China and the rumors about espionage are a much discussed topic in the Netherlands, making the story immediately a political issue.

Samsung Electronics

Official statement from Samsung Electronics

Today at 14:30 CET LetsGoDigital received an email with an official statement from Samsung Electronics:

Samsung makes it a top priority to protect and respect the intellectual property rights of others.

We are deeply disappointed at media reports that had widely assumed or even suggested of Samsung’s involvement in any wrong doing against ASML, which are not true.

While we cannot disclose details of our business deals, Samsung had made precautions so as to adhere to all laws and regulations with its development contract with Xtal, including a clause that specifically prohibits the illegal use of 3rd-party IPs. All products that have resulted from our partnership with Xtal do not interfere with ASML’s IPs.

We would also like to clarify that, unlike media reports, our partnership with ASML has remained strong without discontinuation.